Suggestions for Making Limited Run CDs?

I'm on the board of directors of Spread the Love Charity.  We have organized a huge charity concert with 12 local bands to take place at the end of January.  Most of the bands are donating a song that we are putting on a compilation CD to sell at the event and I volunteered to take the music files and create the physical product.  So far I've created the artwork and figured I could just knock these out with a color printer and a paper cutter and manually assemble them into CD cases.  

We are looking at producing 200 CD's.  So we certainly could duplicate these using a handful of computers, but a quick search of the internet has found a few sites, like this one, which will knock out the disks for $124.  I figured at this price it was well worth my time and sanity to pay someone else to make them.  I've never done this before, so I'm looking for suggestions on the best/easiest/cheapest way to get this done.