Windows Phone Thoughts - Daily News, Views, Rants and Raves

Check out the hottest Windows Mobile devices at our Expansys store!


Digital Home Thoughts

Loading feed...

Laptop Thoughts

Loading feed...

Android Thoughts

Loading feed...




Go Back   Thoughts Media Forums > WINDOWS PHONE THOUGHTS > Windows Phone Hardware

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 09-20-2006, 06:00 PM
Jon Westfall
Executive Editor, Android Thoughts
Jon Westfall's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 3,233
Default The New iPAQ Mobile Messenger: hw6915 - A Tough Package To Beat



Product Category: Windows Mobile 5 Phone Edition Device
Manufacturer: HP
Where to Buy: HP Shop Online
Price: $599.99 USD
System Requirements: ActiveSync 4.2, Exchange Server Account Recommended.
Specifications:416 MHz PXA270 Processor, Integrated wireless
Quad band GSM/GPRS/EDGE, WiFi (802.11b), Bluetooth�1.2, GPS, 1.3 MP camera, thumb keyboard.

Pros:
  • Integrated Everything;
  • Excellent HP proprietary software;
  • Blazing fast graphics performance.
    Cons:
  • Square Screen;
  • Lack of VGA;
  • Keyboard text entry speed.
    Summary:
    So we've all had that moment of saying "Gee, I wish that my device had that built in". I can safely say that I didn't have that thought at all with the hw6915. The iPAQ hw6515's new brother seems to finally get it right on HP's third jaunt into the Pocket PC Phone Edition arena. But can its list of features make up for a few annoying side-effects?

    Read on for the full review!

    In The Beginning
    Many moons ago, in a dark and distant time before I was an Editor at this great site, I was obsessed with a new Pocket PC. The Pocket PC was the iPAQ h6315, a unit with details leaked for well over a year and finally released at the end of August, 2004. At that time, I wrote the following:

    "I am the (for now) lone h6315 vote. After selling my I-mate, and carrying 2 devices again, I NEED to be converged soon! I'm also praying the functionality of the machine will make up for the puny processor / RAM."

    I eagerly drove up to the closest T-Mobile store on the day the product was released, plunked down my cash, and went to my office play with my new toy. Quickly, though, I realized that the h6315 had some "issues". HP, eager to get the device out after numerous delays, hadn't fully tested everything as well as I'd have liked and I spent a few days just chasing bugs down. Next came the issue of that puny processor and RAM - and unfortunately the functionality didn't quite make up for it. While I used the h6315 as my daily driver for almost a year full-time, even I couldn't deny that HP needed a lot of work in the area of converged devices.

    So about a year after the h6315 came out, as I sat reading my email on my 6th h6315 (T-Mobile got to replace a lot of units for me, from having 1 unit completely "melt down" and not boot to one that the vibrate motor had died, and everything in between), I saw information on HP's next converged device, the iPAQ Mobile Messenger hw6515. The hw6515 was a bit more tastefully designed than its older brother. With a square screen and built-in thumb keyboard (as opposed to the removable thumb keyboard on the h6315), the hw6515 seems destined to steal the show and prove that HP could put together one of these converged devices right. Heck, it even had GPS built-in! But all was not rosy for this device - it suffered from a timing issue. Namely, it came out right as Windows Mobile 5 devices were hitting the market, and with the older OS and lack of WiFi, it only was a mediocre success. The hw6515 was nice, but it wasn't something to write home about.

    Now, two years after HP's first attempt, the hw6915 is rolling out. With limited availability as of this writing (available in Europe and Australia), the hw6915 seems to be the answer to all of our needs and the ultimate Treo and Blackberry killer. Through the graciousness of the Microsoft Mobile and Embedded Devices group, I was able to borrow a hw6915 for a few weeks and get to know the newest sibling of my former pal, the h6315!

    A New Unit, Packed With Features
    With all the features crammed into the hw6900 series, it's hard to know where to begin. Let's first take a look at the size and logistics of the unit. The unit is 4.65 x 2.8 x 0.71 inches, and weighs about 6.33 ounces. I lined it up below with my other devices to get some idea of how much bigger or smaller it is. While the JASJAR is clearly the king of size in this group, the hw6900 series is roughly 80% of the width of the JASJAR, making it quite a bit wider than many of the devices out there today. It's also just slightly thinner than the K-JAM, and when combined with the width, the depth gives a good feeling to my larger hands. It's a shame that those with larger hands are more at home with this device than those with smaller, given that thumb keyboards are typically easier to use for those with smaller appendages! Any way you look at it, though, the hw6900 series is not inordinately large or small. If it was approximately 2.4 inches wide I feel it would be perfect, but hey, you can't have everything in too small a package. Check out the pictures below for more comparison shots.


    Figure 1: Side-by-side comparison. 5G iPod, i-Mate K-JAM, i-Mate JASJAR, HP hw6915


    Figure 2: Left sides, JASJAR (bottom), iPAQ, iPod, K-JAM


    Figure 3: Right sides


    Figure 4: Tops


    Figure 5: Bottoms

    Upon turning the device on, you'll see HP's Today screen, with a wireless plug-in and dashboard of indicators. The GPS indicator is truly just that - an indicator. Whereas the other buttons let you enable or disable a radio, the GPS button simply shows the status of GPS, as the built-in GPS is automatically activated and deactivated by GPS software. I know that GPS software isn't cheap to code, but it would be nice to have a built-in GPS app that would simply show GPS data to the user so they could verify the radio was working without having to fire up a full mapping program (even the included one). The dashboard indicators cycle through available system resources, and the HP Profiles applet will bring up a profiles menu, allowing you to select what pre-defined profile you want to use ("Silent", "Car", etc.).


    Figure 6: The default Today Screen.

    One thing that shocked me as I was playing with the settings on this device was the Hardware Buttons applet. Yes, hard as it is to believe, the iPAQ only has 1 hardware button! This made me pause and consider that, while the keyboard does go a long way in speeding up text entry and program launching, hardware buttons can still be incredibly useful. If you're a big fan of them, remember that you're limited by the OS to only 2 functions on this 1 button, so unless you invest in a third-party button mapper, you may have to limit your hardware button use!


    Figure 7: Hardware Buttons - only one!

    Another interesting thing uncovered while going on the settings journey was the headphone equalizer option built right into the device. Kudos to HP for providing native equalizing for those who use their iPAQ for audio enjoyment.


    Figure 8: Headphone equalizer.

    HP includes on some models in the hw6900 series (those ending in "5", the hw6915, 6925, 6945) a 1.3 MP camera, and their own camera software. Pocket PC cameras (and mobile phone cameras in general) do not have a reputation for having the best quality, although sometimes the old saying "The best camera is the camera you have with you" is very true (just ask an unnamed team member here whose car was vandalized a few months back and snapped a picture with his Pocket PC). The software that HP provides is fairly decent, and the pictures the unit takes are fairly similar to any other 1.3 MP picture you've ever seen. The biggest complaint myself and others have had is the latency in the software shutter. Snapping a picture means you snap, your subject holds still for at least 5 seconds, and the cute shutter sound stutters a bit before completing. I don't know why it seems to take longer to snap a picture on this Pocket PC than others, but if you're a heavy mobile picture snapper, it may just drive you nuts. I also noted a GPS button on the view screen, which will let you geocode your pictures with your location. Certain map provides, such as MapQuest can then read the information and pinpoint where you where when you snapped it. Neat!


    Figure 9: HP's bundled camera software, reviewing a picture.


    Figure 10: HP's bundled camera software, the GPS button is an interesting feature.


    Figure 11: Picture taken with 1.3 MP Camera, lower light conditions, no flash.


    Figure 12: Picture taken with 1.3 MP Camera, lower light conditions, flash.

    Performance
    Pocket PC Phone editions have a rather anemic persona that they must overcome in the community. Two years ago, when HP initially introduced the TI OMAP processor in the h6315, the community became fairly disenchanted with it rather quickly. While the battery life was outstanding (up to 7 hours of use on one charge), the slow speed made those 7 hours pure agony at times. Two years later and it seems that the OMAP is on its way out, with successor devices to OMAP Originals (h6315, HTC Wizard) receiving beefier chips. In the hw6900 series, HP chose to go with an Intel PXA270 chip running at 416 MHz, which is a great improvement over the h6315's OMAP 151 at 200 MHz and the hw6500 series' PXA270 running at 312 MHz. More processing power in general plus a few other surprises are revealed by the benchmarks. Let's take a look.


    Figure 13: Spb CPU Index.

    CPU speed-wise, there really are no surprises. The hw6915 falls right about where it should based on its processor speed. HP's challenge, no doubt, was to take a device with a mid-speed processor and improve other areas enough to give the impression of a faster device. What is the most visible feature that users notice in a device? How fast it "feels". Note that the "feels" part is a perception that isn't necessarily tied to speed of the chip. The fastest chip bogged down by another component will feel slower than it really is. One of the key components of our perception of speed is graphics. Let's take a look at how the iPAQ stacks up there.


    Figure 14: Spb Graphics Index.

    WOW! The iPAQ blows away the rest of the units when it comes to the graphics index. In using the device, one of the first things I noticed was how fast it seemed when re-drawing the screen (i.e. switching tabs, etc.). I often get the feeling that I move quicker than the computers around me (this is pointed out to me when others watch me move my mouse or hover my stylus over an area of the screen yet to contain a button), and I can honestly say that the amount of times I found myself doing that with the hw6915 was substantially less than any other Pocket PC I've used.


    Figure 15: Overall Spb Benchmark Index.

    Overall the iPAQ hw6915 scores about middle of the road compared to other recent Pocket PC Phone releases. While it isn't the fastest kid on the block, it certainly doesn't suffer the same chronic slow syndrome as previous Pocket PC Phones. For a daily driver that takes its fair share of use and abuse in a day, it's the right mix of speed and power usage for the majority of users.

    Wonderful Wireless
    Just a few years ago, finding Bluetooth AND WiFi in the same device was unheard of (heck, ask Treo 700w users now if you doubt me...). Now it's the norm for higher-end Pocket PCs. Likewise, today finding WiFi, Bluetooth, and GPS in the same device is nearly unheard of, especially in the United States. When HP initially announced the hw6500 series last year, I was surprised that WiFi was cut in the interest of GPS (word at the time was that the technology simply wasn't inexpensive enough to let the two co-exist in the same device at a reasonable price). Having friends & family who drive a lot, I saw that GPS could be more valuable to them than WiFi, but that WiFi has a higher intrinsic satisfaction to it. After all, when sitting in the coffee house surfing the web wirelessly, one does not usually ponder if GPS would have been more or less valuable to them in guiding them to the coffee house. However, at our core we always want more for less (or the same) and HP decided to deliver that in the hw6900, adding all three wireless radios.

    In looking at the new Communications Manager in the hw6915, one first notices that there is no option to turn on or off GPS, and there are no configuration options for it either. If you're unfamiliar with built-in GPS solutions, they basically switch on and off automatically depending on if an application is requesting GPS data. After loading Pharos Ostia onto my hw6915, I found it had no problem detecting and starting the native GPS, all without any real user intervention. Back to GPS in a moment, but first let's explore the manager.


    Figure 16: The Communications Manager interface, with separate tabs for each radio sans GPS.


    Figure 17: The phone tab, giving links to common areas of phone configuration.


    Figure 18: WiFi options.


    Figure 19: Bluetooth options. The hw6915 series utilizes the Broadcom stack instead of the Microsoft Bluetooth stack.

    As I said, GPS doesn't have its own tab and for good reason - there really is nothing to configure! There is a "Quick GPS Connection" item under settings that downloads a GPS connection file to the device over the network. This file provides information to the GPS radio about what satellites should be in the area. Since it's dynamic information, it does "expire" and can be set to automatically re-download as needed.

    Overall use of GPS was very encouraging. The receiver, aided by its connection file, was able to acquire a lock quickly. I found that simply holding the iPAQ in my car and glancing at the screen (then placing it on the seat next to me) worked fine, however a dedicated mount would be best if traveling in unknown areas. Use of common sense is a big requirement when having built-in GPS as opposed to traditional GPS systems or Bluetooth GPS because of the ease-of-use factor. Previously, setting up my GPS took at least a minute (put receiver on dash, turn receiver on, turn on Bluetooth on device, start software, initiate connection, etc..) and generally was reserved for traveling (when I most likely had my dashboard mount installed) and special occasions. With the hw6915's built-in GPS, turning it on casually is easy, and before you know it you're driving through traffic staring at the device in your hand rather than the cars on the road! That being said, the option to use GPS all the time, even when in familiar "turf" is extremely exciting - I can find alternate routes easily, explore without worrying about where I'll end up, and find PoI's (Points of Interest) easily as I require no special GPS setup "ritual".

    The other wireless radios provide the same experience you'd expect from them. WiFi seems to find my router super quickly (a good thing) and connects without a hitch. Funk Software's Odyssey client is listed as an included item, however it isn't in ROM, so if you need to connect to WiFi networks that require specific authentication schemes, you'll have to install it from the included CD. Bluetooth, implemented with the Broadcom stack, works as expected, and does include support for Bluetooth headphones (as well as the option to route all audio traffic to a standard Bluetooth headset or hands-free device - this doesn't provide great sound compared to the A2DP profile, but is nice in specific situations such as listening to GPS directions through your headset while driving with others). The Bluetooth headphone profile appears to be free of the performance lags that have plagued A2DP integration in other devices.

    Oh, and we can't forget to mention that the device is quad-band and supports EDGE for data speeds as well as traditional GPRS. In my testing, I was able to pull around 130 KB/s on the EDGE network, similar to the speed I pull on my EDGE-enabled K-JAM. EDGE speeds (and GPRS speeds) are dependent on your area, so your mileage may vary. Overall I was very impressed with the radios inside the hw6915, obviously I would have wanted greater support for up-and-coming 3G technologies, but heck - the thing has four different wireless radios - how picky can I get?

    Thumbing Through
    One of the items that interested me most on the hw6915 was the thumb keyboard. With thumb keyboards seemingly in style now, I've found there is a difference between a thumb keyboard and a usable thumb keyboard! The original iPAQ keyboard that came standard on my h6315 consisted of little round buttons, with no backlight which made it unusable in low-light. The hw6500 series keyboard got a backlight (blue) but kept the same basic look. With the hw6900 series, the look hasn't changed much, but the backlight is night and day different than its predecessors. Just check out the pictures below:


    Figure 20: Keyboard close up, no backlight, in a lit office.


    Figure 21: Backlight on, in a fully lit office.


    Figure 22: No backlight, dark office, screen on.


    Figure 23: Backlight in a dark office - anyone need a flashlight?

    As you can see, the backlight on this thing is not dim by any stretch of the imagination. It was actually bright enough for me to use it to navigate a dark house at night! I'd say that's pretty good backlighting, which goes a long way toward total usability. My previous full-time Pocket PC, the i-Mate K-JAM, also included a thumb keyboard, however it was slightly different.


    Figure 24: i-Mate K-JAM keyboard compared to the hw6900 series.

    The differences are fairly obvious, the orientation allows the keys on the K-JAM to be bigger. The keys on the K-JAM were also different than the hw6900 series in other ways. For one, the K-JAM's keys had just enough tactile feel to them to give a good "thumbing" feedback to the user. There was no mistaking if a key had been pressed or not. The hw6900 series notches it up even more with a very resounding "click" noise on each button press. This clicking is very good reassurance that you've pressed a button (not that any of us would be, say, driving and tapping a phone number in or anything), but it can also be a downfall. Namely, it's very hard to tap in messages or notes when sitting in a meeting as others will hear the clicks fairly easily. I resorted to typing out my responses with the stylus on the SIP (screen input) keyboard (i.e. the old fashioned way), but this left me with painfully little room on the screen. If you're concerned about thumb keyboarding un-obtrusively, this device is not for you. The keyboard also, in addition to providing good feedback, features a number pad on the right hand side (compared with the popular Treo which places it on the left). The number keypad becomes active by default whenever you're on the dialing screen, and allows you to enter phone numbers with ease.


    Figure 25: Keyboard options.

    Finally, the hw6900 series keyboard allows the user to change a few small options in Control Panel, including backlight time-out and key repeat control. The option to disable the keyboard seems largely useless to me. This keyboard requires a significant amount of tactile force to press a key, which makes me believe that accidental key presses will be highly unlikely. In placing the unit into a tighter space, such as a jeans pocket, it becomes clear that the joystick, not the keyboard, is the most accidentally-prone-to-activate input feature on the device.

    Daily Drive
    It's interesting to take a new Pocket PC out with you when you're so used to one that more closely resembles the "mold" than the hw6900 series. For many of us, the hw6900 series may be a first jump into the square screen form factor, the first jump into a thumb keyboard on the front of a device, the first time with integrated GPS, the first time with a flip-up screen protector, and the first time with a Pocket PC Phone that has an actual dial-pad on it for dialing phone numbers. Quite a shift from the norm.

    During my first day with the iPAQ, I noticed that the flip-up screen protector could be both a blessing and a curse. For one thing, it kept my facial oils off the screen when I had to take an impromptu phone call (the Bluetooth headset I normally use wasn't even on me). But at other times, it kept far too much light from me to make the screen readable. I ended up perfecting a Captain Kirk-esque move of using my thumb to move the screen protector up a bit, then a slight flip motion to make it click up into place. The good news is that the flip-up protector is quite easy to remove and then reinstall when you're ready.

    As I already mentioned, the keyboard can be a bit loud in meetings, but it is a Godsend when making phone calls. Since the people I call the most are either speed-dials or I know their numbers, punching in a number was a breeze. And when entering new numbers, I didn't have to continually check the screen to see if it got the three 8's in a row, or the alternating numbers (i.e. 3232) in the correct order. Touch screens are great, but they need to be used with styli for accurate text entry, and unfortunately no one usually has the time to pull a stylus to dial a phone number (or no one wants to!).

    The integrated GPS was an interesting experience while driving. I found that I probably engaged in more unsafe driving habits than I should have, since I now had the GPS with me more and could turn it on easier. Watching yourself as a dot on the road is not good when you're controlling the dot. Anyone who thinks they may fall into this trap of going "aw neat!" and powering on GPS for trips to the store, etc.., may want to get a dashboard mount - quick!

    Finally, the square screen is an issue I'll address. Never having used a square screen device before, I was unsure of what to expect. I knew the community was polarized about the issue, with some instantly discounting a device with a square screen and others not seeing it as a problem. I quickly learned that when coupled with a good input method (i.e. the thumb keyboard), the square screen was not a significant issue. However, if I had to activate a screen SIP for anything, I became painfully aware of the lack of screen real-estate. The moral of the story - if you're good with your thumbs, and don't think you'll use any SIPs on the screen, then I don't see the square screen posing a big problem. If you're more of a block recognizer person, then you may be slightly annoyed.

    Overall the hw6900 series gives great usability, in my opinion, and packs features in that will enhance your daily drive, work, and play. Just be careful how you use them (i.e. the GPS) and be aware how you plan on using the device (i.e. SIP or thumb keypad) before buying.

    Conclusions
    Overall I'm very impressed with how far HP has gone from the early attempts at a Pocket PC Phone. The hh6300 series problems are long forgotten and the hw6900 series has many new features that are hard to find rolled together on another unit. Aside from the relatively high price tag in the US and the fact that it's an HP (a turn off for some given the time it takes HP relative to other OEMs to bring things to market), I find no serious complaints about the device or the logistics of securing one. Yes, VGA, a larger screen, and slightly bigger keyboard may be my desires, but the all-encompassing feature set and general ease of use make the HP hw6900 series a winner in my book.

    Jon Westfall lives in Ohio, mainly in a house or office, and with his wife & cat. When not writing about Pocket PCs or decision making paradigms, he is quite active in his hobbies of sleeping, eating, and reclining on sofa-like objects. He maintains a mediocre blog at JonWestfall.Com.
  •  
    Reply With Quote
      #2  
    Old 09-20-2006, 06:19 PM
    dmbourdon
    Neophyte
    Join Date: Aug 2006
    Posts: 7
    Default yea but...

    This sounds like an amazing device but being on the Edge network (vs. EVDO), downloads are going to be s-l-o-o-o-w.
     
    Reply With Quote
      #3  
    Old 09-20-2006, 06:34 PM
    Tony Rylow
    Editor Emeritus
    Tony Rylow's Avatar
    Join Date: Dec 2005
    Posts: 214

    After seeing this device in person, I must say that I am quite impressed with it. While I did not get to see the GPS in action, it sounds like a great feature to add to an already great platform. I currently use an MDA as my DD, but after seeing this, I'm considering making the switch. The only things holding me back are the slightly larger size of the device (I have smaller hands), and the current lack of funds.
     
    Reply With Quote
      #4  
    Old 09-20-2006, 07:40 PM
    marky_uk
    Neophyte
    Join Date: Jun 2006
    Posts: 4
    Default All good except ....

    I have had this device a few months now and love it, having upgraded from the 6310 over here in the UK

    The integrated Wifi is a godsend over the 6310 + wifi card I had before - basically, the Spectec wifi card, for all its beauty did two things - 1) it gobbled battery like nothing else. Really, I mean in a few minutes another percent was gone. And 2) It intermittently worked. That's not a typo .... I got sooo bored of restarting the device, taking out card, putting back in, restarting, re-installing drivers ... ahh, a nightmare.

    This wifi just works. And discovers. And has better wifi management software as you've said.

    The downside for me? The battery has to go a long way to be really really useful for me, particularly if away from home for any length of time. If you're moving from a mobile to this, then be prepared for a culture shock in battery life - you're basically getting push eMail, a big bright colour screen, wifi and other things which put a drain and strain on the battery ... I can just get a day out of the device if I'm out and about and must charge every night.

    The other downside is the typing .... I don't know what HP are doing but the 6310/15 was terrible at typing ... it would miss every second or third keypress and you'd have to press it again. This does it about every fifth or ninth keypress - still a problem if you're trying to write plenty.

    Re the screen - it's really not an issue at all. I was on Palms for years and got fed up of trying to write really fast when my brain was dishing out ideas faster than I could scribble. Having to pause the brain when it's in free-flow is terrible. Paper and pen win over every time. This can just about keep up with it's full useful keyboard!

    Overall, Jon has this pretty well described as it is - it's everything in one package. I still use an iPod myself as I want plenty of tunes and don't want to crash out my mini SD cards if my iTunes/WMP is playing up as I use it for TomTom maps and backups.
     
    Reply With Quote
      #5  
    Old 09-20-2006, 08:33 PM
    T-Will
    Sage
    Join Date: Feb 2002
    Posts: 784

    Quote:
    So about a year after the h6315 came out, as I sat reading my email on my 6th h6315 (T-Mobile got to replace a lot of units for me, from having 1 unit completely "melt down" and not boot to one that the vibrate motor had died, and everything in between)...
    Sorry, haven't finished reading the article yet, but this brings back memories of another HP (Compaq) device...it was the blessing and the curse of the Pocket PC world...I can't quite remember what it was called (I think I blocked the name out of my mind). :lol: I just remember having to go through 5 units before I got one that was in okay condition.

    Okay, now I'll finish reading...
    __________________
    T-Mobile Dash | HP iPAQ 4100 | HP iPAQ 2210 | HP iPAQ 1910 | Intermec 6651 | Toshiba E570 | Compaq iPAQ 3600 | Casio Pocket Viewer
     
    Reply With Quote
      #6  
    Old 09-20-2006, 09:16 PM
    joerobin
    Neophyte
    Join Date: Jul 2005
    Posts: 3
    Default Re: All good except ....

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by marky_uk
    The other downside is the typing .... I don't know what HP are doing but the 6310/15 was terrible at typing ... it would miss every second or third keypress and you'd have to press it again. This does it about every fifth or ninth keypress - still a problem if you're trying to write plenty.
    I've had my device over a month, and the keyboard has been flawless (knock on wood).

    I LOVE the GPS. Mine came with TomTom 5. I have a 6965.

    But the most coveted feature is FREE Push Email (I have my own Exchange Server).

    A great device indeed. But they still need to work on the camera.

    I'm tempted to get the memory upgraded from 64MB to 128MB by PocketPC Techs, but I'll wait a little longer for that.

    Joe
     
    Reply With Quote
      #7  
    Old 09-20-2006, 11:02 PM
    crispeto
    Intellectual
    Join Date: Apr 2002
    Posts: 151

    The "where to buy" link states it is $599. Is that unlocked? In other words, can I purchase this phone for $599 and put in my tmobile sim card and that's it?
     
    Reply With Quote
      #8  
    Old 09-20-2006, 11:02 PM
    ricksfiona
    Pontificator
    Join Date: Jul 2003
    Posts: 1,041
    Send a message via AIM to ricksfiona

    What's the difference between the 6940 and 6945? They cost the same but are two different models. What gives?

    This is REALLY tempting... I was waiting for the HTC Excalibur, but that's only a Smartphone. With a better keyboard (that's really important when wearing motorcycle gloves), ACTUAL PDA functionality AND GPS (useful when on long motorcycle rides).. WiFi, BT AND available now... I'm trying not to pull out my bank card....

    So, what's the difference between the 6940 and 6945 again ;-)
    __________________
    Rick Gomez - Owner/Consultant
    fiona Systems Integration
    www.fionasystems.com
     
    Reply With Quote
      #9  
    Old 09-20-2006, 11:03 PM
    poiuyt
    Neophyte
    Join Date: May 2006
    Posts: 3
    Default Not very portable

    I noticed none of your pictures showed the cables that came with the device. My 6915 came with a 4x4x2 inch power brick and a USB cradle. As with past iPAQs, it uses a propriatary data connection. There is no way I could travel with that power brick and cradle (the USB cable could at least have been designed to unplug from the cradle for easy packing).

    The feature set on this device really excited me. I thought I would replace the Mio A701 I use daily with it. Instead it sits collecting dust.

    Cons:
    1) Does not have standard mini USB jack
    2) USB cable is part of a giant cradle
    3) Does not charge from USB
    4) Power brick is huge
    5) It is larger than any other modern device except the JasJar (HTC Universal)
     
    Reply With Quote
      #10  
    Old 09-20-2006, 11:45 PM
    T-Will
    Sage
    Join Date: Feb 2002
    Posts: 784

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by ricksfiona
    This is REALLY tempting... I was waiting for the HTC Excalibur, but that's only a Smartphone.
    This is the same dilema I'm in...should I wait for a PPC Phone edition that's the size of the HTC Excalibur/Moto Q, or just go for the Smartphone? The only minor problem I see is I have a few spreadsheets (gas mileage) that I like to fill out on the go and Smartphone doesn't have Pocket Excel/Word (yet), I guess I can always set a task to edit the spreadsheet when I get home.
    __________________
    T-Mobile Dash | HP iPAQ 4100 | HP iPAQ 2210 | HP iPAQ 1910 | Intermec 6651 | Toshiba E570 | Compaq iPAQ 3600 | Casio Pocket Viewer
     
    Reply With Quote
    Reply


    Thread Tools
    Display Modes

    Posting Rules
    You may not post new threads
    You may not post replies
    You may not post attachments
    You may not edit your posts

    BB code is On
    Smilies are On
    [IMG] code is On
    HTML code is Off

    Forum Jump


    All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:04 PM.