01-06-2007, 08:00 PM
|
|
Executive Editor
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 29,160
|
|
Zune Ugly Truth #2: Embedded Album Art Not Supported
BACKGROUND: With its big, bright screen and display of CD cover art while playing a song, it seemed like the Zune was going to be the ultimate audio player for visually-oriented people like myself. Yet when the first Zune reviews were starting to trickle in, several of them made similar comments to this:
"Despite the larger screen, many album covers look worse than they do on the iPod." - Walt Mossberg
I couldn't figure out why the early reviewers were saying this, and quite honestly I chalked it up to them not knowing how album art was supposed to look. I sent a friend of mine (who had a pre-release Zune) an MP3 from an independent artist that had big, glorious 600 x 600 pixel embedded album art, and asked him to load it onto the Zune. He sent me a picture (which looked great) and I published a glowing article about how great it was that the Zune displayed embedded album art. It was especially noteworthy because the Toshiba Gigabeat S and other PMC devices did not display embedded album art. I was thrilled - until I bought my Zune and saw that, indeed, the quality of the cover art was horrible. What was going on? Why did I think the Zune displayed embedded album art?
PROBLEM: The Zune does not display embedded album art. I misinterpreted what I was seeing from the test I had my friend do and made a false assumption about it. I've done a lot of experimenting, and you can rip a CD with something like Exact Audio Copy (to get a 100% perfect bit for bit copy), use MediaMonkey to embed high resolution 600 x 600 pixel album art, then use the Windows Media Player 11 to play the song, and all is good with the world - you'll see the big, full-resolution album art in the Now Playing window. But the second that WMP11 is used to scan a folder and import the music into its library, it scans the MP3s and extracts the album art, resizing it to 200 x 200 (the Zune software now does 240 x 240, more on that later), compressing it to about 50% JPEG quality, and creates four JPEG files in the same folder:
- AlbumArt_{C8489A4E-6A61-4807-9614-EF63D5E65B54}_Large.jpg (200 x 200 pixels)
- AlbumArt_{39FD80B4-4429-4822-8765-F8058A39FEA1}_Small.jpg (75 x 75 pixels)
- Folder.jpg (200 x 200 pixels)
- AlbumArtSmall.jpg (75 x 75 pixels)
C8489A4E-6A61-4807-9614-EF63D5E65B54 above is the album ID and will be different for every album you have in your library.
These smaller, highly-compressed images are what get displayed on the Zune when the files are synchronized. This album art looks horrible. We're talking really, really bad. How bad depends somewhat on the album: some, without any text and mostly black and white, will look vaguely passable. Others, especially anything with rich colours like red and orange or smaller text, look extremely bad. The Zune screen is 240 pixels wide by 320 pixels tall, and it looks like the album art on the screen is being displayed at about 240 x 240 pixels. The JPEG compression is really what kills the quality though: massive artifacts, ugly image blockiness. The blurriness from stretching the 200 x 200 pixel image just adds insult to injury.
But Jason, what about the new 240 x 240 JPEGs from the Zune 1.2 software update? Yes, the Zune team made things better recently (before I started writing most of this) by kicking up the resolution of the album art by 40 pixels. The extra 40 pixels do make a difference, and album art looks better. But it's still way over-compressed and doesn't look as good as I know it should. I need to do some more testing and comparisons, but I'm pleased to see that they realized this was a problem and acted fast to correct it (hey, this is Microsoft after all, two months after launch is quite fast). You shouldn't have to remove and re-add all your music to get the 240 x 240 album art though - there should be a way to force the re-generation of album art.
Still...I go from having the custom-scanned, 600 x 600 pixel, lightly compressed AMAZING looking album art to the smaller, high-compressed art that the Zune software creates. I've confirmed that the album art is based on the embedded art and not something that the Zune software downloads from an online database - I have some indy CDs that I know aren't in their database and I'll still get album art when synchronizing my Zune for instance.
WORKAROUND: There's no known workaround for this issue. I'm investigating whether someone can create a MediaMonkey script to allow for batch converting of embedded album art to overwrite the default images created by the Zune software, but I've hit a snag as the one script I've found is buggy and I'm waiting for the developer to fix it. Once he does, I may have an awesome workaround.
PROPOSED SOLUTION: The Zune should be able to read embedded album art. Period. Even if the 240 x 240 album art becomes less-compressed, and the quality improves, there are going to be situations where the user will have files on the Zune without separate album art files - reading the embedded art is the real solution. As for why embedded album art is a better approach than the separate file solution Microsoft currently employs, well that's a discussion for another day...
|
| |
|
|
|
01-07-2007, 10:35 PM
|
|
Neophyte
Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 5
|
|
this issue is one of the many things that need to be tightened up with software patches. album art, drm skipping, no custom eq...there are a list of usability issues that keep the zune from being a serious competitor to the ipod.
i do like my zune but annoyances like these make it hard to sell it to others.
|
| |
|
|
|
01-08-2007, 03:19 AM
|
|
Editor Emeritus
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 1,221
|
|
Now I'm kicking myself for not saving my full-sized scans for the few covers that weren't online. But, if I DON'T use WMP11, will it just stick with 240? I have not been embedding my artwork and at this point, it doesn't sound worth it if it's going to get messed over anyway.
|
| |
|
|
|
01-08-2007, 09:40 AM
|
|
Pupil
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 32
|
|
You are correct that the "Zune" device itself does not read the embedded Album Art. Heck, the iPod doesn't either. Really.
As you said, the "Album Art" is transferred at sync by design. It is resized to 240 x 240 at that time, which is the native resolution of the "Album" display on the Zune. (I'd agree they should probably use slightly less JPEG compression, but it's pretty good.)
The Zune Software should use the embedded image in the WMA, MP3 or M4A file (if it exists) over Folder.jpg or the GUID based images as the source Album Art image it converts. It does on both of my machines. Really. All my art looks great on the Zune. Not sure why some people don't see this. I generally use 400 x 400 embedded JPEG, and try to limit the image size to under 75K if possible. (If using MP3, remember to always use ID3v2.3 -- never touch ID3v2.4!)
Didn't we cover part of this before, somewhat? http://forums.thoughtsmedia.com/showthread.php?t=466
Anyway, the real "UGLY TRUTH": Zune Marketplace content uses 150 x 150 resolution art embedded in the files, supposedly a left-over flaw from their initial negotiations with the content provider. That generally looks like garbage converted to 240 x 240.
Using "Find Album Info" will pull better (200 x 200) art over, but it doesn't get used. Why? Since the embedded art takes priority, you are stuck with it unless you manually remove the images from the WMA tracks using "Edit Track Info" or another application. Good times.
It's likely folks using Marketplace will have a bad impression of Album Art on the Zune.
Last edited by grommet; 01-08-2007 at 09:52 AM..
|
| |
|
|
|
12-28-2007, 05:39 AM
|
|
Oracle
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 853
|
|
I'm trying to get caught up here. The Zune 2 does support embedded album art, right? Thanks!
|
| |
|
|
|
12-31-2007, 06:08 PM
|
|
Oracle
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 853
|
|
I've answered my own question - yes, it does!
|
| |
|
|
|
02-03-2008, 06:51 PM
|
|
Neophyte
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 1
|
|
Hi there, new to the forum and curious with the album art problem. Is it really bad? I'm really think hard on what to get my sis for a b-day present coming up and my choices are the mini zune (4/8), the Zune 30 (since its just an extra $20 bucks for more space), or the iPod nano. I'm mostly leaning to the Zune 8GB, the 30 is little bit too big and the zune 8 is good size for her run. I'd get the nano but I want to try something different. If it does look bad, I'll proably get the ipod nano. Also curious about media playback, mostly with videos. Will it play itunes format fine? I have all my movies and tv shows ripped to 480x320 mp4 format and will that run fine on the zune? I know she will want to come over and take some shows (mostly House) and put it on her device but I don't want to re-rip it again. Thanks in advance and have a great day. ^_^/
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
Hybrid Mode
Similar Threads