HP 4705 or Axim 51V?

[jbachandouris]

I have a 4705 and expect a 51V from FedEx tomorrow. I like the 4705, but with any case on it whatsoever it becomes huge in my front pocket. However, going to Aximsite, there seems to be a few issues with it; ie. ROM update v12 and needing the 'fake server' trick so it won't turn on automatically.

I'm not looking for side by side comparisons, just opinions. I've owned both before and not sure what's my best option.

The thing that makes the HP a good deal is the price I paid-$220 from eBay-including HP bluetooth keyboard, travel charger and aluminum case. HP will extend the warranty for 2 more years for $150 (since it is already 1 year old).

Any advice?

[Brad Adrian]

I haven't personally owned a 4705, but am completely sold on my X51v. I haven't had any problems with the ROM, but I have done the fake server trick. That little hack takes about 60 seconds to perform and has done the trick 100% for me. So, I'm very happy with the screen, dual slots and overall size.