Log in

View Full Version : A Look at 5-Minute Clinical Consult 2006 with Diagnosaurus


Darius Wey
02-03-2006, 05:00 PM
<img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/wey-20060204-5MCC01.gif" /><br /><br />Over the years, <a href="http://www.5mcc.com/">5-Minute Clinical Consult (5MCC)</a> has become one of the indispensable clinical texts in the medical industry. Unbound Medicine, in association with Lippincott Williams &amp; Wilkins, recently introduced a handheld version of the 2006 text, which in many ways, beats carrying around the actual book. Read on for a quick look. <!><br /><br />The 5MCC application is broken into two parts - the primary 5MCC text, and Diagnosaurus (a differential diagnoses tool). The interface is simple, thus making the application very easy to use. At the top (see Figure 1), there are two bars. The first bar allows you to switch between 5MCC and Diagnosaurus, though when viewing actual clinical material, it changes to a title bar. The second bar contains a drop-down menu which allows you to switch between different sections. For example, in the main 5MCC index, you can switch between clinical topics, medications, and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICD-9">ICD-9 codes</a>. Deeper into the text, within a particular "chapter", that menu changes (discussed later in the review). At the bottom (again, see Figure 1), there are also two bars. One is a toolbar, consisting of a Back button, a Home button, an Index button, and a Text Size button (with five different options). The other is a dynamic search bar that filters through the vast amount of information on-demand.<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/wey-20060204-5MCC02.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 1: The easy-to-use 5-Minute Clinical Consult (5MCC) user interface.</i><br /><br />Opening a particular topic, medication or ICD-9 code brings up the relevant "chapter" of the text. It's broken up into six main sections - Basics, Diagnosis, Treatment, Medications, Follow-up, and Miscellaneous. Each section is nicely organised; detailed reference material is formatted with blue headers, black text, and bullet points for easy reading. You can navigate between these different sections using the menu bar discussed earlier, but also using the Previous and Next buttons situated in the bottom-right corner of the screen. Toward the top-right corner, you'll notice a button graphically portrayed with a set of blue and red arrows. This is a Related Information button which conveniently links to relevant topics in Diagnosaurus.<br /><br />Everything in 5MCC is clinically detailed. All the topics contain information on statistics, signs and symptoms, causes, risk factors, diagnosis and associated procedures, clinically relevant laboratory tests and results, pathological findings, imaging, treatment, medications (both advised and alternative), follow-up care, and other miscellaneous factors. It sounds like a lot, yet amazingly, all this occupies only 4.2MB on the device. And, I haven't even discussed Diagnosaurus yet!<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/wey-20060204-5MCC03.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 2: The Diagnosaurus - mammoth in size, though hardly extinct. ;)</i><br /><br />Diagnosaurus is a differential diagnoses tool for signs, symptoms and diseases. It contains over 1000 common presentations, and links directly to the primary 5MCC text. The user interface of Diagnosaurus is no different. The drop-down menu of the Diagnosaurus index presents three different sections - Organ System, Symptoms, and Diseases. Clicking on a particular topic within a section brings up material consisting of an etiology list (possible causes of a condition) and a DDx list (a list of alternative diagnoses) where relevant.<br /><br />Like before, the Related Information button (in the top-right corner) links to relevant topics in the primary 5MCC text.<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/wey-20060204-5MCC04.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 3: Medicine Central offers an easy-to-use, web-based, over-the-air service for 5MCC/Diagnosaurus and many other texts.</i><br /><br />Unbound Medicine also provides a web-based <a href="http://www.unboundmedicine.com/medicine_central_pda_wireless.htm">Medicine Central service</a>, alongside the 5MCC/Diagnosaurus software package. It contains a drug reference (Davis's Drug Guide), test manual (Pocket Guide to Diagnostic Tests), and a MEDLINE journal tracking and searching service. The portal has been designed for both desktop and mobile use, so it formats itself nicely in a mobile browser such as Internet Explorer Mobile.<br /><br />There is a lot to love about the handheld version of 5MCC: zero bulk, dynamic searching, and tight integration with the added Diagnosaurus tool. If you're a medical student or physician who demands on-the-spot facts for a huge number of clinical conditions, then Unbound Medicine's package is definitely worth a look. There is a free trial version on <a href="http://www.unboundmedicine.com/5mcc_5-minute_clinical_consult.htm">this page</a>, and if it tickles your fancy, you can purchase the full version for $64.95. Considering all the extra features that can be derived from an electronic version of the text, I think it's well worth the money spent.

Muntasser
02-03-2006, 05:26 PM
Hi. As a medical student myself I can vouch for the quality of the 5MCC-2006 program.

The SmarTabs systems is great, and this program is a truly useful "whip out and see" application. When I'm taking a history or in transit during a ward round and I'm unsure of a disease I can get a heads up on the spot --> this is priceless.

My only criticism of this program has to be that it isn't the messiah of consult programs, obviously obscure conditions such as anti-synthetase disease will not be covered, but for the bulk of your clinical practice using 5MCC and searching the differentials with Diagnosaurus (free last time I checked) isn't a bad way to be.

If any other healthcare professionals in this forum know of a superior app than 5MCC for looking up conditions I would really appreciate a PM or post in this thread.

Cheers/

NB:I dont work or have any interest (financial or otherwise) with whoever it is writes these apps...

silverpilot03
02-03-2006, 05:57 PM
If you download and register the FREE Diagnosaurus, the e-mail confirmation will include a 20% discount offer for 5MCC and other titles.

(I am not connected in any manner to any of these businesses/sites)

DoctorsGadgets
02-04-2006, 08:44 PM
Saw this via MedicalPocketPC.com. Very good review, nice breakdown of the functions. I agree with the above posters that 5MCC has been an 'essential' for med students and docs for a while. It's nice to see integration with Diagnosaurus too.

BTW several companies now publish this with slightly different interfaces. This page (http://www.5mcc.com/handhelds.html) shows all the different versions available - I believe that most have free trials so you can decide which one you like best.

Muntasser
02-05-2006, 03:07 PM
too right. My version of 5MCC is from Skyscape. It doesnt have natural integration with Diagnosaurus - however there is a "workaround" for Skyscape users.

[MobileDDx™ - Differential Diagnosis Tool] from Skyscape is almost identical to Diagnosaurus (plus SmarTabs layout) and is compatible with the very sweet cross-linking technology from Skyscape.

Only catch --> it costs $19.95 or 50% off with the purchase of 5MCC.

tanalasta
02-13-2006, 01:55 PM
too right. My version of 5MCC is from Skyscape. It doesnt have natural integration with Diagnosaurus - however there is a "workaround" for Skyscape users.

[MobileDDx™ - Differential Diagnosis Tool] from Skyscape is almost identical to Diagnosaurus (plus SmarTabs layout) and is compatible with the very sweet cross-linking technology from Skyscape.

Only catch --> it costs $19.95 or 50% off with the purchase of 5MCC.

I'm another fan of Skyscape products over Unbound Medicine having purchased and used both over my medical career. What annoys me is the activation/installation process which requires an activesync and an internet connection which can be dreadfully slow (and occasionally screwed the entire device over... requiring hard reset) though it may be much improved now.

5MCC I prefer over another favourite of Skyscape/medical users - the Oxford Handbook of Clinical Medicine. However indispensible it is, I haven't found "quick reference" as useful anymore - the major caveats being you need to know what the diagnosis is before looking it up, with the other disadvantage (in the world of evidence based medicine) is that 5MCC, being American (I think) often differs from Australian practice.

jeremyjoslin
11-03-2006, 01:25 AM
I've used the Epocrates Essentials for the last year, but my subscription just expired and I'm not sure if I'm going to re-up. I'll still use the drug lookup, but have been considering other apps for dx lookup. Epocrates bundles 5minCC with their paid versions. Any comments on how the Unbound version is better/worse?