which to get Dell Axim X5 or HP 1910

[Bloop]

So here’s the big question which PPC should I get?

Dell Axim X5 Handheld (400MHz one)
Or
HP 1910 (I do understand that this is impossible to find in a store)

I like the HP 1910 mainly b/c of its size! It’s pretty much as big as a Palm Zire’s. (I have an iPaq 3765 which I am selling on eBay right now, and the main thing I hated about it was having it in my pocket because it was so big, and it kept banging against my leg) (BTW the Blue Zire case looks like it would fit the HP 1910 perfectly, but i wonder what its made of and how hard it is)

On the other hand there is Axim which I hear is pretty large and bulky, I would really like to know what it size comparison to another PDA.

Axim does have the CF slot and the SD slot, which tempts me in to getting an 80211. But I am wondering what other CF cards are worth getting?

In addition the Axim also has a 400MHz x-scale which is pretty nice but how much better is a 400 x-scale over a 200 x-scale and is there really a need to have that much processing power on a PDA. (My 3765 had a strong ARM 206 and I never really had any issues with processing speed, their was one exception a SNES emulator, which ran super slow)

Another big thing I am looking into is a service plan type deal for the PDA, best buy has the best service plan for getting the HP, but I was wondering if anyone with an Axim could explain to me what Dell’s "1 Year Advanced Exchange Service" covers and if its any good.

Thanks for your time, BTW it’s my first post so if some already asked a similar question sorry, I ‘m a noob to these forums.

[CodeSurge]

Between the two, I'd go with the Axim. Although the h1910 has the uber-small form factor going for it, it lacks an SDIO slot - which is a deal-maker/breaker for me. Do note that there are apps out there which allow you to overclock the 1910 to 300MHz or higher, so the CPU speed isn't such a big deal anymore.

The Axim (don't have one, but I've played around with it) isn't as bulky as it's made out to be. Sure, it's not as slim as the h1910 and the V35 (which I use), but it's definitely slimmer than the old Casios and even the Hp 56x series. All that power for that low price. ;)

[Bloop]

what does a SD I/O slot allow me to do, use a bluetooth sd card? what other sd cards are able to be used on PPC

[blazingwolf]

Right now there aren't to many sdio cards that are available. The only 1 I know of is the Toshiba bluetooth card. However, I'm sure more are going to be available sometime this year. I use the SD slot for memory and that leaves the CF slot open for bluetooth, wifi or more memory. I like the Axim and it is not really all that big. Nice to have SD and CF built in. Plus it cost the same as the 1910.

[WindWalker]

An SDIO slot would allow you to use any of the new Secure Digital form factor I/O cards that are (or should be) coming to market in the upcoming months, which would include Bluetooth, WiFi, and the like. Non-SDIO capable devices (such as the 1910 and the Axim) are restricted to using SD for storage only, at this moment upto 1 GB (if you are willing to sell your car and firstborn child).

[Traveller]

I'd go with the Axim, especially if you want to connect to the Internet. The 1910 is basically a standalone unit with no connectivity (lacks SDIO slot) and a connection to the internet can occur only if you're connected to a PC on the internet via Activesync.

[vincentsiaw]

if you buy an axim, you then go back to square one, the same problem with your ipaq 3765, the bulk!

[Bloop]

if you buy an axim, you then go back to square one, the same problem with your ipaq 3765, the bulk!

yea i know thats the main reason why i am hesitating to get the Axim, if it was smaller this would be so much easier.

[Bloop]

Is their anyone who owns a Axim that can tell me more about Dell’s "1 Year Advanced Exchange Service" that it comes with and if they feel its any good:?:

[spursdude]

So here’s the big question which PPC should I get?

Dell Axim X5 Handheld (400MHz one)
Or
HP 1910 (I do understand that this is impossible to find in a store)

Most of what you want depends on what your needs are...i.e. if you want an expandible powerhouse, go with the Dell - you get two expansion slots, a faster processor, and more ROM space. The faster processor will be important if you do more intense tasks like gaming or multitasking with playing MP3s and doing other intensive tasks at the same time. You'll also appreciate the Axim's better batteyr.

If you want something sleek and pocket-able, definitely go with the iPaq. It only has an SD slot, but it's definitely much better looking (the Axim looks fine, though). The form factor is definitely amazing, and you'll love the screen too. But if you're going to want to get online with your PPC or get a lot of accessories, the 1910 probably isn't for you.

BTW - I don't think you can use Zire faceplates on an iPaq...besides, why would you want to? :D