C|Net Test-Drives SLR-Wannabe Compact Cameras

[Suhit Gupta]

<div class='os_post_top_link'><a href='http://news.com.com/8301-13580_3-9767018-39.html?part=rss&subj=news&tag=2547-1_3-0-5' target='_blank'>http://news.com.com/8301-13580_3-9767018-39.html?part=rss&subj=news&tag=2547-1_3-0-5</a><br /><br /></div><i>"In the course of writing a story about compact cameras that have some characteristics of higher-end SLR (single-lens reflex) cameras, I informally tested some cameras to see how they fared. The bad news is that I was a bit disappointed, though I recognize the impossibility of affordably reproducing the full abilities of a bulky, big-sensor SLR in a pocket-size package. The good news is that there's progress on the horizon. In the month since I tried a handful of models--the Ricoh Caplio GX100, the Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX2, the Nikon Coolpix P5000, the Canon PowerShot G7 and the Olympus SP-550 UZ--the last two have been replaced by more capable successors. Overall, I liked the GX100 for its high image quality, raw support and serious feel. My other top pick was the G7--although it's bulkier and doesn't support raw images, it produced solid photos and is probably better suited to mainstream shooters. The most promising new arrival is the Canon PowerShot G9, the newest member of the G series that's specifically targeted at the discriminating crowd."</i><br /><br /><img src="http://www.digitalmediathoughts.com/images/powershot_g7_front_20060914_270x202.jpg" /><br /><br />When I started reading this article, I was expecting the Canon G9 to show up at the top of the rankings. It turns out that the G7 was the one that was actually reviewed and as expected, it performs quite well when SLR like features are the expectations. Of course, Ricoh surprises by coming in at the top with their GX100. Do any of you use a Ricoh?

[marlof]

I use the Ricoh GX100. And it's the first small camera that I'll actually use. Other cameras stayed behind, since I didn't really care for either the lack of control or the awkward way to control the camera. Although the Ricoh is not a replacement for a DSLR (my outdated E-1 gives nicer pictures than the Ricoh), it is compact, has good manual control, and the images from it are nice enough. So when I don't care for carying a DSLR and one or two lenses, I take the Ricoh. It's a fun camera.

[Jason Dunn]

I use the Ricoh GX100. And it's the first small camera that I'll actually use.

It looks interesting, but that big periscope that comes out the top - is that as awkward as it looks? :?

[marlof]

It looks interesting, but that big periscope that comes out the top - is that as awkward as it looks? :?

It's actually a great benefit: a detachable EVF. You can take it off, and only have the square camera, where you can use the screen for framing. Or put it on (in Periscope style), and use the EVF (great in bright sunlight, when you don't want your screen visible, or when you prefer the extra stability pressing a camera to your face gives you). The EVF is even tiltable, so you can also use it as an angle viewer for shots like this one:

http://marlof.smugmug.com/photos/170684159-L.jpg

where I didn't have to go flat in the grass to take the shot.

[randalllewis]

It seems a similar feature to the outstanding Canon variable LCD that has been around since the G2 up to the G6 Powershots, sadly abandoned in the G7 and new G9 but- happily- now found on the S series cameras. While I am one who doesn't like the loss of viewfinders on digital cameras these days because using the LCD screen adds to the chance of a camera shake, I do love having the option that Canon and Ricoh have provided for getting creative shots. Waaaay too many people think the only way to take a picture is while they stand erect with the camera at eye level. There is lots to see from way up hi and down low.