Log in

View Full Version : MSN Direct Watch Hits the SPOT


David McNamee
02-09-2004, 04:00 PM
I stopped wearing watches while I was a college senior. I had developed something of a nervous habit of repeatedly looking at my wrist to check the time. Like Alice’s white rabbit, I constantly felt as though I were late for something very important. It took me about six months to recover from the confused feeling of not knowing the current time down to the millisecond. I began to go about my days with a more relaxed attitude and I began to feel better. I swore that I would never wear another watch again. <br /><br /><img src="http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0001540G4.01.MZZZZZZZ.jpg" alt="User submitted image" title="User submitted image"/> <br /><br />That was 1997. For seven years, no watch has been strapped to my wrist.<br /><!> <br /><span><b>Enter SPOT</b></span><br />A little over a year-and-a-half ago, I began to read about Microsoft’s plan to bring connectivity and data to everyday appliances that weren’t thought of as data consumers. Microsoft Research had been demonstrating concepts of these devices known as Smart Personal Objects, or SPOT. The refrigerator magnet that showed updated sports scores was pretty neat. The connected alarm clock they showed was ingenious. It was going to show the time, the current weather conditions, traffic alerts, and your agenda – so that you could decide if it was safe to hit the snooze button. I knew that once these devices eventually came to market, it would be added to my increasingly digital lifestyle. I thought it would be wonderful to wake up in the morning and have just enough information staring me in the face to help orient me toward my day. Then the news came. The first SPOT-enabled devices to market would be – wristwatches! I decided right there to hate the SPOT-enabled wristwatch and wait for other devices to come along that would better fit my lifestyle choices.<br /><br />Then, my curiosity got the better of me. I broke down and bought a SPOT watch.<br /><br /><span><b>It’s Not the Size of the Watch That Matters…</b></span><br />I purchased the Abacus Wrist.NET watch from Fossil at a local CompUSA. They also carried the more expensive N3 from Suunto. I decided on the lower-end model since I was determined to hate it anyway. The Abacus has a black, plastic wrist band that fit me pretty well straight out of the box. The band looks to be adjustable by removing a pin from one of the clasps. I haven’t tried this, so please read the manual before you make any adjustments. The watch itself is pretty big. It is smaller than many of the sports watches you’ll see, but it is still relatively large. The size alone makes this a niche product for male geeks. There isn’t a lady with an ounce of fashion sense in her that would strap this beast onto her wrist. Fortunately for me, I am both male and geek, so I put on the watch and continued. <br /><br />The digital watch face can be chosen from a dozen different available faces. I settled on split face that gave me the current time in my time zone and in another time zone. I chose my second time zone as Pacific US since I frequently have to think in Redmond time when working with Microsoft. There’s also some extra goodness with the watch face that you don’t hear much about in the press reviews. The Abacus has a built in stop watch with basic functionality. I put it through a field test a couple of weekends ago when I used it to keep track of my pace during a 5k race. There is an alarm, of course. You can actually set two different alarms. There is also a nifty countdown timer. I’ve used this in place of my egg-timer in the kitchen a couple of times. The watch can also be customized to display 12 or 24 hours time, different date formats, and measurements in US or metric units.<br /><br /> <img src="http://www.smartphonethoughts.com/images/SPOT_Face.jpg" alt="User submitted image" title="User submitted image"/> <br /><br /><span><b>That’s Great, But What About the Data?</b></span><br />The switchable watch faces and other features are nice, but I was ready to turn this into an information appliance. Maybe that would help me forget that I was dealing with a watch. I signed up for the MSN Direct service that powers the data being sent to the watch. MSN Direct works by broadcasting data over FM radio subcarrier frequencies. There is a very strong FM receiver built into the watch that picks up the unregulated frequencies and delivers the data to your watch. Once the watch starts receiving data, it automatically adjusts to the correct time and time zone. There is a very wide assortment of data services to choose from once you start receiving data. You can get news headlines from the AP, Reuters or MSNBC in local, national or international flavors. Science and technology news is also available from those providers as well as Space.com. Stock and weather information can be received, and these bear closer examination. For stock data, you are shown the current trading price. You are also shown a five-day chart with high/low values and volume data. The weather information is even better. You are presented with the current temperature, the forecasted high/low for the day, a three-day forecast, sunrise and sunset times, the wind chill, barometric pressure, humidity and the UV index. You may also choose up to 10 additional cities to receive their high/low information. I currently get weather for Orlando, Seattle, Calgary, Quebec, and London. Not only do you receive this plethora of data, but the watch also picks up your current location and displays the correct local weather. When I drive from Tampa to Orlando and back, the watch updates itself to give me correct information!<br /><br /><img src="http://www.smartphonethoughts.com/images/SPOT_Weather.jpg" alt="User submitted image" title="User submitted image"/><br /><br /><img src="http://www.smartphonethoughts.com/images/SPOT_News.jpg" alt="User submitted image" title="User submitted image"/> <br /><br />You can also receive personal information on your watch. The MSN Direct service supports synchronizing with your Outlook calendar. You install an add-in for Outlook that lets you push updated calendar information up to MSN Direct. That data is then forwarded to your watch. The watch notifies you at your set reminder time. MSN Messenger 6.1 has been updated to support MSN Direct. People on your buddy list can send messages directly to your watch. This has come in handy more than once in the last few weeks. Your calendar data and personal messages aren’t just floating out in the open for all to see, though. Personal data is encrypted before being broadcast. Every watch has a unique identifying number on it and that number is used to tag and encrypt data being transmitted. Your watch reads data that has its tag, decrypts it and displays it on the watch.<br /><br /><span><b>So What? My Smartphone Can Do That – Sort Of…</b></span><br />A question that I’ve been frequently fielding is why I would want a SPOT-enabled watch with MSN Direct service and a Smartphone? There are SMS-based services that provide headlines, stock quotes, and weather information. Why is getting that data on the watch any better? I find that it is better for two key reasons: higher data quality and lower intrusiveness. The information I receive through MSN Direct is much richer than SMS messages relaying the same basic data. The weather forecasts give me pictures that clearly and quickly show me if rain is expected. The stock trends can be shown graphically. You can’t get that kind of meaningful presentation from plain text in an SMS message. The information is also less intrusive to receive than an SMS message. When I get an SMS message, I have to grab my phone, scroll to the inbox, and open the message before reading it. Most messages to my watch can be taken in completely with a single glance. Last week I got an instant message on my watch from Mike, our new contributing editor, during a conversation with a student. When I glanced at my watch to read Mike’s message, the person I was speaking to didn’t know that anything interesting had just happened. I couldn’t have done that with an SMS message. The watch is a wonderful complement to my Smartphone.<br /><br /><span><b>Don’t Leave Home Without It</b></span><br />SPOT-enabled watches aren’t yet perfect, but they have raised the bar for version 1 releases. The physical attributes need work – smaller, more varied designs need to come out for mass appeal. Also, some of the news headlines need work. They are sometimes chopped off at awkward points in the sentence. Overall though, I am very pleased with this Abacus watch. Despite my best efforts, I can’t bring myself to hate it. In fact, it and my Smartphone are always with me when I leave home. Having certain information at the ready has had its advantages. Looks like I’m back to wearing a watch!

Mike Temporale
02-09-2004, 05:43 PM
Great review David! I'm very intrigued by SPOT watches, and I think you're experiences have pushed me that much closer to getting one. 8)

possmann
02-09-2004, 08:04 PM
ditto on that Mike....

I just wish they could receive pages - that would be the ultimate!

spg
02-09-2004, 09:56 PM
Nice review David. I agree with you on alot of things there... SPOT isn't perfect yet, but it is quite good for a version 1 release. I also use the Fossil Abacus (same watch face even :)), and really like it. Right now I'm really looking forward to the sports scores channel coming out.

Also, good thoughts on how the SPOT watch can complement a Smartphone. This has been something asked of me alot as well, and I think you covered it very well. That is almost exactly how I explain it to people as well.

Malte
02-09-2004, 09:58 PM
I would definately get one, if MSN Direct was avaliable in Europe. Do You know if, and if so, when Microsoft will launch SPOT over here?

spg
02-09-2004, 11:12 PM
Microsoft hasn't said anything publically about moving to Europe with MSN Direct/SPOT. I think they will certainly look at it in the future, but not until they are sure they have a working and (mostly) bug-free system in the US and Canada.

arnage2
02-10-2004, 04:14 AM
I might get one, to. I wont have to rely on finding hotspots for news.

possmann
02-10-2004, 04:41 PM
Dave - does this have a silent alert setting? I'm a bit concerned about being in a meeting and having the thing beep at me several times because news, weather and sports get updated... I would, however, not mind if the watch beeps and it is a message from a contact - just not a news update...

Being locked into the Messenger (6.1) protocol is very limiting - I can't use that at all with our company as we've locked those messenger features (yahoo, MSN, AOL) down - 0 access. Being closer to Microsoft than I am (which doesn't say much for me - :lol: ) I'd love to learn if they plan on the following items:

customizable alert features - briefly asked about above
ability to page the watch or to send a message to the watch directly - not having to use msn messenger
opening access to other IM protocols - I've got quite a few friends using Yahoo IM and would like to make it easy on them to send me an IM from a app they are used to using...

Mike Temporale
02-10-2004, 05:06 PM
I can't use that at all with our company as we've locked those messenger features (yahoo, MSN, AOL) down - 0 access.

:( I know how you feel. My client has blocked all IM traffic and any web based email site. It would be nice if there was other means to send a message to the watch. Even if it was integrated somehow into the MSN site.

spg
02-10-2004, 06:00 PM
Dave - does this have a silent alert setting? I'm a bit concerned about being in a meeting and having the thing beep at me several times because news, weather and sports get updated... I would, however, not mind if the watch beeps and it is a message from a contact - just not a news update...
Well, I'm not Dave, but I know the answer. :) Unfortunately this is an area where the SPOT watch (at least the Abacus) is lacking a little. You have three options for sounds, and those are either "All on", "Alerts only", and "All off". To turn off the beeping for news alerts you would have to use the "all off" setting, which would also turn it off on message alerts. Weather doesn't ever have any alerts, and the sports scores channel is not released yet.

Being locked into the Messenger (6.1) protocol is very limiting - I can't use that at all with our company as we've locked those messenger features (yahoo, MSN, AOL) down - 0 access.
I agree, it is very limiting. Alot of people I know use MSN IM, but certainly not near everyone who might want to send me a message.

Being closer to Microsoft than I am (which doesn't say much for me - :lol: ) I'd love to learn if they plan on the following items:

customizable alert features - briefly asked about above
ability to page the watch or to send a message to the watch directly - not having to use msn messenger
opening access to other IM protocols - I've got quite a few friends using Yahoo IM and would like to make it easy on them to send me an IM from a app they are used to using...
I really don't know about their plans in this area... but, I will forward this thread onto my SPOT contact at Microsoft, I'm sure they will take a look at it. They are very actively looking at user feedback to improve on the product and service.

David McNamee
02-11-2004, 04:25 AM
I might get one, to. I wont have to rely on finding hotspots for news.

News is one area that could use some improvement. Like I mentioned, sometimes the headlines are a bit awkward. When you read the paragraphs that accompany the headline, you get the general idea but are not told where to find more information. It would be nice if there was some article id included so you could visit the news providers web site and get the full-lenght article.

Of course, that would assume the news provider had article ids...

David McNamee
02-11-2004, 04:34 AM
Dave - does this have a silent alert setting?
Like Spencer said, it's an all or nothing deal. However, you can configure the news channel to not send messages for breaking news. That way, the news will never cause your watch to beep.

I'd love to learn if they plan on the following items:
customizable alert features - briefly asked about above
ability to page the watch or to send a message to the watch directly
I suspect the logic behind using MSN Messenger was so that you as the user have control over who can and cannot send a message to your watch. The idea is for this device to be unintrusive. If any schmoe with a POP3 account can ping your wrist, than it could get annoying.

opening access to other IM protocols - I've got quite a few friends using Yahoo IM and would like to make it easy on them to send me an IM from a app they are used to using...
Sounds like a job for Trillian!

David McNamee
02-11-2004, 04:41 AM
Microsoft hasn't said anything publically about moving to Europe with MSN Direct/SPOT. I think they will certainly look at it in the future, but not until they are sure they have a working and (mostly) bug-free system in the US and Canada.

Plus, I have zero clue as to how FM frequencies are regulated in other countries. If they can't use the same frequencies as they do in North America, they'd have to ship different versions of the watch. That would stink to go to, say, Japan, and not be able to use it for anything but telling time.

David McNamee
02-11-2004, 04:44 AM
Also, good thoughts on how the SPOT watch can complement a Smartphone. This has been something asked of me alot as well, and I think you covered it very well. That is almost exactly how I explain it to people as well.

I've actually unsubscribed from all of my SMS services except for sports and breaking traffic conditions. Two items not yet available through MSN Direct.

David McNamee
02-11-2004, 04:50 AM
Well, I'm not Dave
You don't know how lucky you are... :wink:

Perry Reed
02-16-2004, 10:37 PM
Great review! (And great to know that it works here in Tampa...)

I've been wanting one of these for a long time, pretty much ever since I heard about them. But now I've got my eyes on the Suunto N6, due out this summer, which combines the SPOT features with several others typical of their high-end sport watches.

Sadly, I'll never be able to afford one... :(