Windows Phone Thoughts - Daily News, Views, Rants and Raves

Check out the hottest Windows Mobile devices at our Expansys store!

Digital Home Thoughts

Loading feed...

Laptop Thoughts

Loading feed...

Android Thoughts

Loading feed...

Go Back   Thoughts Media Forums > WINDOWS PHONE THOUGHTS > Windows Phone Thoughts Sponsored Articles

Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 05-09-2004, 05:29 AM
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 1

It's been about a week since my commentary was posted, I thougt it was time for me to respond to some of the replies. Here are my comments in no particular order.

First, it's great to see the general support of gaming on Pocket PC's and Smartphones. They really are great games machines.

Let me just say I have nothing against dedicated gaming machines such as the Game Boy. In fact, I just got a Game Boy Advance. I'm a huge fan of Advance Wars. You guys are right, most of the GBA games are awesome compared to Pocket PC and Smartphone game (at least in terms of game play, not always in terms of graphics.) The reason isn't the hardware or the inability of the designers or coders, it's simply that you can't sell enough games on the PPC and Smartphone to justify the development cost that would be needed to match the games on GBA. These games are not cheap to produce. We're putting a lot into Lands of Shadowgate our multiplayer game on Pocket PC and Smartphone!

My point was that I don't think that this will be very everyone. Nintendo has sold a huge number of Game Boy's (100m+) and will probably continue to do so. However, compared to the phone business this is small. Last year 500m phones were sold worldwide. Most people would be perfectly happy with a phone that played games.

Personally I'd own both and play games on which ever I had a available at the time or whichever had the games I wanted to play.

Regarding XNA. I don't think that Microsoft's announcements about XNA mean that they won't be doing a handheld gaming machine. In fact, their point with XNA has been that it will help with cross-platform development from Xbox to PC to Windows CE/Mobile. There's no real reason they couldn't add XBoy to that list. (That name has been used by a number of authors to refer to a fictional Microsoft handheld gaming machine. I have no more insight on this than anyone else.)

I agree with the various people who said that the controls and feel of a gaming machine are critical. The Game Boy Advanced SP feels great. It has all the right buttons in the familiar and comfortable spaces. If anything Pocket PC designers seem to have repeatedly shot themselves in the foot. Why would you make a navigation control that doesn't recognize diagonals or multiple button presses. I think only the Casion Pocket PC's have ever done a good job with this and they're not in the business any more. (BTW, it's not like the Palm devices do any better. Take a look at the buttons on a Clie or Palm Zire sometime!)

However, this isn't hard to solve. If Microsoft just made these elements part of the spec for the Pocket PC and Smartphone all the devices would be somewhat gamer friendly, certainly better than they are today.

I'd like to also say I agree with the people who feel that Microsoft could bring out a high-end handheld gaming device to compete with the Sony PSP. I don't disagree, they could. It's going to be interesting to see what price the PSP ships for next year. It could be expensive, e.g. $200-$300 after all it's quite the piece of hardware according to rumors (we'll all know more this week as I'm sure they reveal details at E3) At that price it will be a while before they see sales in the 25m+ range. Yes, gamers will pay almost anything for a decent game machine but these devices only sell more than 25m when they get below $150-$200.

To repeat the point, a really good game enabled phone could sell 100m+ in a year. This would give us a good size market and the ability to do great original games! We can't as long as the market remains so small.

This leads to the readers point about exclusive titles. You're right I should have touched upon this. Microsoft hasn't to date done much in the way of gaming on the Pocket PC or Smartphone itself (Cubicle Chaos, please!) If it did and the rumors seem to point that way for next year, this would help a great deal. It would bring credibility to the idea of these devices for gaming. Having said that I think that evern Microsoft would start with conversions of their existing games before going to original games.

Regarding the price of phones and getting a phone for free. Of course there is no such thing as a free lunch and you're really paying for the phone. However, a lot of people are happy with the idea of paying an extra amount on there phone bill each month for a year or two than having to dish out $200-$300 at once.

I agree with the people who like the Zodiac! The guys at Tapwave did a great job of turning a Palm device into a game machine. This is now what Microsoft should look to do. The only problem with the Zodiac is the price, it's way too high. They need to lower the price, eat the losses and make it up by charging a small royalty for games. The market would be much bigger and even though we'd be paying something to Tapwave we'd win in the end by selling more to a larger market. Microsoft will almost certainly learn from this. They usually do.

The Gizmondo looks promising but here's the problem. I'm a game publisher, we've got 10 games for the Pocket PC, four for the Smartphone and more coming. You'd think they'd want to talk to me, right? I've tried several times to contat them by phone and by email and NEVER received a SINGLE response. I don't get it. They may ship a cool device but I don't know what games will be available unless it plays all our games with no changes and they're just playing it close to their chest. Again, my concern is with price, it will probably be too high for most people. We'll know more about this one too next week, it looks like they have a booth at E3 too (For those of you who don't know, E3, or the Electronic Entertainment Expo. is THE annual trade show for the gaming industry) I'll be there, I'll post something if it looks like it's for real.

Let's keep this discussion going here and elsewhere. If you want great games on your Pocket PC and Smartphone, support great games. We can do some really innovative stuff (sign up for the Lands of Shadowgate beta and see for yourself but only with the support of the Microsoft, the manufacturers and game players!

Eugene Evans
Infinite Ventures
Reply With Quote
Old 05-14-2004, 09:32 PM
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 47
Default Gizmondo vs. Zodiac

I don't think the Gizmondo will "blow away" the Zodiac at all...

The Tapwave is not trying to be a portable gaming machine... it's trying to be a good PDA and good gaming device combined. It's not the best gaming machine and it is not the best PDA, but it good at both.

The Gizmondo is a gaming machine built on Windows CE OS... it is NOT a pda.

Besides that... while I don't have the specs real handy, I'm pretty sure the Zodiac's screen is bigger, I'm pretty sure if has more memory, and I'm pretty sure that the Gizmondo does not have dual SD slots.
Reply With Quote
Old 05-15-2004, 04:22 AM
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 18

This months random lurker post

If I where a Sega executive, I would really compel MS to release a version of the PMC (Portable Media Centers - aka mini MCE) that allowed gaming (heck= the controls are already similar to gameboy) Sega has a excellent brand perception already, and the PMC I predict will have an excellent following even without gaming. But I always want more, and this would be an ideal combination.

The DRM subscription model introduced with Janus ( would allow online would allow online purchasing or even renting of games (with Napster 2.0 meets Gamefly flavor).

Also, if manufacturers don’t include some high mega pixel camera device in this…I’ll be very disappointed. Almost all research shows cameraphones that support pictures…and now videos, are a hugely popular…but disappoint users due to there bad image quality and no easy way to archive or sync the pictures onto your Home PC. In addition, high quality camera attached to a portable media device is would easily create synergy as they share many of the same components (LCD, Storage, UI, Controls).

I’d like to see Cellphone/Internet linked in there, but I don’t think the technology is there yet for a 2004 launch. Data is still slow and expensive…and although Verizon recently announced 2.4mbs burst / 300kbs substained) coverage in my new residence of San Diego, I don’t believe it will happen anytime soon nationwide. In my opinion, by the 2005/2006 when broadband wireless is everywhere, are super hip Windows Mobile Longhorn phones will do everything (Gaming, Video, TV, Music, Internet, Wireless Headset, Remote X10 Control of environment, and possibly Secure RFID proximity purchasing).

Reply With Quote

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:01 PM.