HEH I've been so hyped over these things the last few months that I've almost convinced myself to just go out and buy one the day they came out. Then I remembered MS's track record on product released. Mainly that it usually does take them 3 attempts to get anything right. From Windows NT to Pocket PC to Tablet PC. So I think I need to step back from the buzz for a second and take a critical look at the Tablet PC. I'm going to hold off on one until I can walk into CompUSA or Best Buy and spend an hour playing with one.
My biggest concern is MS's disregard for handwriting recog. There are more then a few articles where MS has disregarded handwriting recog as the most important thing on the Tablet PC. *scratches head* Huh? What would happen if my keyboard only recognized 1 in 10 keystrokes? Handwriting recog IS the most important part of the device simply because it is the core method of interacting and inputting info into that device.
Personally I think when MS disregards something it usually means they can't get it to function right out of the box which could be a serious buzzkill for the Tablet PC.
What MS should have done is just gone to Apple and licensed whatever tech they used in the Newton's handwriting recog for the Tablet PC. TO date the software on my Newton is close to 90% accurate for me. Along with the previous “gripes” I also want to know:
- How do device manufacturers plan to deal with the potential for the device to be scratched? Do they have a better surface? Writewrite for the Tablet PC? Since the pen uses a EM method of input it doesn’t require direct interaction with the surface so a cover of some sort should work. Last thing I want to do is spend 2K+ on a new device and scratch the bloody thing within a weeks time.
- Is anyone else planning on releasing better handwriting recog? CalliGrapher for the Tablet PC anyone?
- What companies are on board to support the Tablet PC. From what I’ve heard Adobe is going to be supporting it which should be interesting. Specialized version of Photoshop anyone? What other companies?
I don’t know. I’m cautiously optimistic with the Tablet PC. But I need to play with one before I make any decisions. If nothing else I may very well hold off until Dell decides to jump into the market. I’ve always been a big fan of Dell products. If they have decided to hold off on releasing a Tablet PC there usually is a good reason and that reason may very well apply to me as well. *shrugs* Time will tell. If anything I’m most likely going to stop by a CompUSA or Best By November 7th and see what they have to offer.
[This has been a Jonathan rambling. We now return you to your regularly scheduled posts]