I'm looking to get new cellphones for 3 family members who are mainstream (non-PDA/smartphone) users on AT&T, since their contracts expire end of this month. They all prefer physical keypad buttons so that rules out the 3G iPhone
I can't decide whether to get them all the new
AT&T Motorola Z9 or this unlocked HTC Touch Dual US version. Direct from AT&T the Moto Z9 is subsidized to $200 for renewing customers (I think $300-350 otherwise). I believe the Z9 phone itself is only available in the US with an AT&T firmware. Whereas the Touch Dual US version is $550 unlocked from Best Buy, usable with AT&T or T-Mobile.
I consider the Moto Z9 (
4.49" x 2.11" x 0.55" @ 4.94oz) to be AT&T's best feature phone in slider formfactor. HSDPA 3.6, 2.4" (non-touchscreen) QVGA, side buttons with haptic vibration feedback, A-GPS with LBS, 2MP cam with LED, MP3/AAC/WMA/Real player with PlaysForsure, microSDHC, stereo BT, speaker-independent voice dialing, micro-USB data/charging port with audio, Opera browser, old proprietary Synergy OS, etc.
Most reviews extoll the Z9's excellent build, display, voice quality and signalling. AT&T firmware means out-of-the-box support for all features such as AT&T Navigator turn-by-turn directions, AT&T Mobile Music (Napster/XM), AT&T Video Share, etc.
The Touch Dual
US version (
4.21" x 2.17" x 0.62" @ 4.23oz) has a lot of the same features, along with Windows Mobile 6.1 Pro, 2.6" QVGA touchscreen with TouchFLO finger interface, 20-key phone/QWERTY combo with SureType, more built-in user memory, etc. It doesn't have GPS nor camera flash though (and no Wi-Fi either!). But obviously WinMo offers great advantages such as Exchange with push, and all the 3rd-party software. On the other hand, not being customized for AT&T means some of the carrier's features aren't conveniently available.
In the end the Touch Dual does sound great, especially for my family members who already use Exchange. But how
easy is it for them to use compared to a the Moto Z9 feature phone with AT&T firmware? I don't have experience with the latest HTC WM 6 phones, but no one in my family ever liked using any of my previous Pocket PCs! Too clunky in everyday use...