[myeclectica]

Hello,

I'm looking for some feedback on an eBook reader comments, ratings and review site I'm working on.

The site: www.myeclectica.com

Specifically looking for some constructive criticism on:

- Devices listed: Currently have some dedicated devices but thinking of expanding to include devices shown in the "Question" section.
- General overall look and feel, flow
- Missing content or areas that should be expanded
- Thoughts on the ratings given in each device page
- Testing of the comments, poll and ratings tools

Thanks.

This is a "hobby" site and not a business so please be gentle with me. ;-)

Thanks again.

[myeclectica]

Hello,

I'm looking for some feedback on an eBook reader comments, ratings and review site I'm working on.

The site: www.myeclectica.com

Specifically looking for some constructive criticism on:

- Devices listed: Currently have some dedicated devices but thinking of expanding to include devices shown in the "Question" section.
- General overall look and feel, flow
- Missing content or areas that should be expanded
- Thoughts on the ratings given in each device page
- Testing of the comments, poll and ratings tools

Thanks.

This is a "hobby" site and not a business so please be gentle with me. ;-)

Thanks again.

[Steve Jordan]

A critique of the site:

Although your intent is worthy, the site does need to be fleshed out in two areas:

One, the descriptions for the individual readers need to be polished (it looks like you pulled text from other sites, and that caused some text errors that need to be fixed) and expanded upon.

Two, your addition of a "PDA" category doesn't really work here, as there are so many styles and formats of "PDA"... it is too generic a category. I'd suggest choosing a few PDAs in particular, or perhaps a PDA, a smartphone, and another device like the iPhone or an ultra-mobile PC (UMPC), and giving each their own category... or simply leave PDAs out.