iPods Get Cover Flow, My Zune Gently Weeps

[Jason Dunn]

<div class='os_post_top_link'><a href='http://crunchgear.com/2007/02/26/ipods-to-get-cover-flow-firmware-update-coming-soon/' target='_blank'>http://crunchgear.com/2007/02/26/ipods-to-get-cover-flow-firmware-update-coming-soon/</a><br /><br /></div><p>We don't post about the competition to the Zune very often, but every now and then if we see a feature on another digital media player that we'd like to see on the Zune, we'll talk about it.</p><p><br />There's a <a target="_blank" href="http://crunchgear.com/2007/02/26/ipods-to-get-cover-flow-firmware-update-coming-soon/">video floating around the Web</a> showing an iPod displaying a new eye-popping feature: Cover Flow. iTunes on the desktop has it, and while it's pretty cool looking, they way they implemented it leaves a lot to be desired (most due to the position of it in iTunes, I find it awkward and bolted-on). The iPod implementation, however, fills the screen and looks great (assuming that this is real and not an elaborate and amazingly well done fake). Check it out:<br /></p><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/yFwEcmn26zI" width="425" height="350" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent"></embed><p>No matter which side of the iPod love/hate fence you fall on, there's no denying that the effect shown is just damn cool. If you're a visual person like I am, that often picks music to listen to based on the album art, this is a very useful way to move through your music. I'm not sure that I buy the usefulness of the scroll-wheel here, but I suppose it's an acquired taste.</p><p>How does the Zune measure up? I'm sad to say not all that well. Before this iPod update, the Zune had a more impressive album art story, if only marginally: the iPod was limited to a small cover that sort of floated in the middle of the screen with a big white border. Nothing impressive there. The Zune, on the other hand, used the album art to greater effect, filling the whole screen with it. The dark secret we all learned when we got our Zune is that even if you have fantastic, high-quality album art inside your audio files, the <a target="_blank" href="http://www.zunethoughts.com/news/show/545/zune-ugly-truth-2-embedded-album-art-not-supported.html">Zune will ignore it</a> and instead serve up the highly-compressed, 240 x 240 JPEGs that can look really bad. I cringe whenever I look at album art on my Zune - the quality just isn't there.<br /></p><p>Now that the iPod is getting the Cover Flow feature, the Zune is again on the defensive. iTunes uses nice quality 600 x 600 images for album art now, and I'm willing to bet they keep the resolution the same on the iPod, use nice bicubic scaling, and don't re-save it and crush the quality. Their album art is going to look good, and the Zune's album art...not so much. </p>

[David Tucker]

You're absolutely right and they best get their butts in gear over at MS. The first real update for the Zune needs to come sooner rather than later.

[Darius Wey]

iTunes uses nice quality 600 x 600 images for album art now, and I'm willing to bet they keep the resolution the same on the iPod, use nice bicubic scaling, and don't re-save it and crush the quality. Their album art is going to look good, and the Zune's album art...not so much.

Sigh, you're right. Album art does look good on the iPod. I just can't work out why Microsoft sticks with compressed 240 x 240 (worse, 200 x 200 for PFS devices).

As for Cover Flow on existing iPods, I'm not 100% sure that it's not just a fanboy's half-minute video aimed at putting the online community in a spin. It's still a question mark as to whether the iPod has the processing power to handle it.

[Dyvim]

I'm pretty sure that video is a fake. There's just no way last year's (really 2005's) iPod can handle that kind of graphic load. My XP laptop with 1 GB RAM and a 3.4 GHz Pentium 4 can barely handle it (iTunes Cover Flow). That said, now that iPhone will support Cover Flow, I bet the next video iPod will do it as well.

iTunes leaves all your album artwork embedded in your music file intact. (I know because I recently lost my music collection due to hard drive failure and had to recover what I could from my 60 GB iPod.) Now as to whether the iPod directly reads the embedded artwork or whether iTunes renders the artwork into a cache of thumbnails for display, I don't know.

iTunes has a lot of 600 x 600 artwork, but there are also many albums with 300 x 300 artwork only. Not sure why. You'd think iTunes could get 600 x 600 artwork for their entire catalog or at least for all major artists.