Log in

View Full Version : Socket's Bluetooth connection kit reviewed


Andy Whiteford
08-27-2003, 06:30 PM
Those of you who have been fortunate enough to pick up one of HP's latest Pocket PCs will have a wireless capability built in under the guise of Bluetooth. There are other manufacturers who also have built this capability into some of their handhelds but if you have a device which lacks this technology but has a compact flash slot, help is at hand. Socket's Bluetooth Connection kit is one viable solution and a very good one at that.<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/andyw-aug03-bluetooth-1.jpg" /><br /><!><br /><i>The Bluetooth connection kit from Socket includes a CD ROM, manual and PCMIA sled to go along with the card itself. Speaking of the main hardware, it's as small a card as you can expect in Compact Flash format, the same size as Compact Flash memory and because it's compatible with Type I, will be usable in any device with a Compact Flash slot. Due to the small nature of this card, there have been misleading reports that the antenna is actually internal and that this will impact on performance. On the contrary, the antenna runs along the top of the card which will be the outer most edge when installed in your Pocket PC meaning it has a good window to your Bluetooth partners. It also means there are no protruding parts to this card making it ideal to leave installed when using a case for example.</i><br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/andyw-aug03-bluetooth-2.jpg" /><br /><i>Figure 1: Contents of the package</i><br /><br /><span><b>Software</b></span><br />Installation of the Socket Bluetooth driver is straight forward. Once installation is complete, the standard Bluetooth icon will appear in the task tray in the lower right corner of the screen. This icon is your link to turning the card on or off as well as accessing the available Bluetooth services. This icon also lets you know the current state of the card i.e. blue for on or greyed out for off. As with any plug-in peripherals, it's important to ensure they are turned off when not in use to conserve precious battery power so this icon colour change is a welcome indicator. Tapping this icon pulls up a menu which provides access to the various services and properties.<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/andyw-aug03-bluetooth-3.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 2: The Bluetooth icon and resultant menu</i><br /><br />The Bluetooth connection kit for Pocket PC offers the following services:<br /><li>General Access<br /><li>Service Discovery<br /><li>Serial Port<br /><li>Dial-up Networking<br /><li>LAN (via PPP)<br /><li>Fax<br /><li>Generic Object Exchange<br /><li>Object Push<br /><li>File TransferSetting up a connection with another Bluetooth-enabled device is simple and intuitive thanks to the use of wizards that guide you through the process step by step. It's also possible to connect to a Bluetooth enabled printer using third party printing software such as PrintPocketCE.<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/andyw-aug03-bluetooth-4.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 3: Retrieving a list of services from a device is simple</i><br /><br /><span><b>Using the services</b></span><br />I never had the chance to try out every service on offer but had no issues with the ones I tested. Pairing my Pocket PC with my Sony Ericsson T68i is as simple as selecting the mobile phone option, selecting the phone from the list and completing the steps in the wizard. I was literally dialing out using my mobile phone over Bluetooth in a about a minute. ActiveSync follows a similar process using its own wizard to have me syncing with my desktop via a USB dongle in no time. LAN access including my shared Internet connection and transferring files were equally as simple to set up and this is a good sign of the strength of Socket's software package.<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/andyw-aug03-bluetooth-5.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 4: The wizard guiding you through setting up a mobile phone connection</i><br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/andyw-aug03-bluetooth-6.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 5: Searching out local Bluetooth devices</i><br /><br />All previously discovered devices are stored which saves time when looking to find and connect to a new service. If you have more than one device of a particular type, say a PC at home and one at work to Sync with, you can set one as a favourite which makes connections a little easier when working with multiple devices. Usually Bluetooth options such as making your Pocket PC discoverable or whether authentication is required are on offer. Socket Dialer software is also included which allows you to select a contact on your device and dial their number via your connected mobile phone.<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/andyw-aug03-bluetooth-7.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 6: And getting a list of all the services a device offers</i><br /><br /><span><b>Performance</b></span><br />I never had any issues with connecting and using the services I mentioned above. For the connections to my PC, I used a Mitsumi USB class 2 Bluetooth dongle and was able to sync or use LAN facilities from anywhere in my house. For the cable replacement technology that Bluetooth is, this is quite impressive and bodes well as a form of short distance networking. Certainly distances of up to eight or nine metres through walls is achievable and possibly more depending on the equipment you are connecting to. Connections remained solid and robust through testing and I used LAN access for approximately 45 minutes without any connection loss. Using this card from Socket does have a noticeable impact on battery life but this is entirely expected from a form of plug in wireless card and never gave me any cause for concern.<br /><br /><img src="http://www.pocketpcthoughts.com/images/web/2003/andyw-aug03-bluetooth-8.gif" /><br /><i>Figure 7: Select how your device appears to others</i><br /><br /><span><b>Gotchas</b></span><br />The Bluetooth connection kit from Socket is an expensive option compared to similar solutions on the market and this is the only real issue I can find that may put any potential buyers off.<br /><br /><span><b>Where to buy</b></span><br />Socket's Bluetooth Connection Kit for Windows CE is available from <A HREF = "http://www.mobileplanet.com/private/pocketpcthoughts/product.asp?dept%5Fid=5120&pf%5Fid=MP580203&listing=1" target = "blank">Mobile Planet</A> for $129.95 USD. [Affiliate]<br /><br /><span><b>Specifications</b></span><li>Max Power Output 90mA (Idle 16mA / Typical 40 mA)<br /><li>Pocket PC 2000 or higher<br /><li>Up to 30 ft (10 m)<span><b>Conclusion</b></span><br />Bluetooth is technology that many people love to hate or have issues with and I wasn't sure what to expect with this being my first foray into its use. I'm glad to report that Socket made this an uneventful and straightforward introduction with the services that I tried being a short hand held (no pun intended), wizard driven ride away! With the card remaining safely tucked away during use, easy to use software and a more than acceptable operating range, I can wholly recommend this connection kit to anyone looking for a compact flash based Bluetooth solution.

nirav28
08-27-2003, 06:50 PM
None of these bluetooth solutions provide a headset/handsfree profile.

Would scream from joy :mrgreen: if I could dial with my PPC and at the same time talk on my bluetooth headset or directly into the ppc using the built in microphone/speaker.



Also, how well does this work with other thirdparty apps such as mphone? does the address book dialing conflict with mphone? anyone know?

kaliwete
08-27-2003, 08:48 PM
None of these bluetooth solutions provide a headset/handsfree profile.

Would scream from joy :mrgreen: if I could dial with my PPC and at the same time talk on my bluetooth headset or directly into the ppc using the built in microphone/speaker.

Also, how well does this work with other thirdparty apps such as mphone? does the address book dialing conflict with mphone? anyone know?

I've used mPhone and PhoneKing (trial versions) on a Toshiba e740 to dial my SE t68i which transfers my the call to my SE HBH-30 headset. Had no problems with the Socket CF BT card once it's paired correctly.

Also used IA PhoneManager to compose/send SMS msgs and update my phonebook on my phone.

However, there is no pairing for headset to PDA yet. Check out the article on Manufacturers short-sightedness on Bluetooth integration (or something like that). :|

Kevin Daly
08-27-2003, 09:01 PM
However, there is no pairing for headset to PDA yet. Check out the article on Manufacturers short-sightedness on Bluetooth integration (or something like that). :|

I might be engaging in delusional thinking (time for my beer medication), but I seem to remember reading somewhere (tried to fish it out, can't find a bookmark for it) that the iPAQ 5550 supports the headset profile.

Andy Whiteford
08-27-2003, 09:10 PM
I believe the h1940 supports the headset profile as well but needs to be enabled via a registry hack. I would assume this could be done with any recent HP model that supports Bluetooth.

Jason Dunn
08-27-2003, 09:20 PM
However, there is no pairing for headset to PDA yet. Check out the article on Manufacturers short-sightedness on Bluetooth integration (or something like that). :|

I might be engaging in delusional thinking (time for my beer medication), but I seem to remember reading somewhere (tried to fish it out, can't find a bookmark for it) that the iPAQ 5550 supports the headset profile.

Yes, the 5550 does, but the 2215 and 1900 series devices do not.

kaliwete
08-27-2003, 10:01 PM
However, there is no pairing for headset to PDA yet. Check out the article on Manufacturers short-sightedness on Bluetooth integration (or something like that). :|

I might be engaging in delusional thinking (time for my beer medication), but I seem to remember reading somewhere (tried to fish it out, can't find a bookmark for it) that the iPAQ 5550 supports the headset profile.

Yes, the 5550 does, but the 2215 and 1900 series devices do not.

OK, so now what can you do with it? Anyone using thier BT headset with thier Ipaq 5550? What cool things can you do?

acronym
08-27-2003, 10:29 PM
maybe I'm doing something wrong, but using the socket bluetooth cf card with ppc2003 isn't so smooth.

For instance, without socket's drivers, I can't connect through activesync or my t68. With socket's drivers I can't use bluetooth file transfer.

Also, with socket's drivers I constantly get errors along the lines of 'unable to find bluetooth hardware' because socket's driver go around ppc2003's built in wifi/bluetooth drivers.

If I now go into the bluetooth setting in ppc2003, I get an error "there is no bluetooth hardware installed on this device." When I try to transfer a file using bluetooth file transfer on the desktop, I can find the pocket pc, but get an error "device does not have the necessary services."

This all worked find with ppc2002...

ctmagnus
08-27-2003, 10:54 PM
OK, so now what can you do with it? Anyone using thier BT headset with thier Ipaq 5550? What cool things can you do?

Wait till HP comes out with a ROM upgrade that enables the SIM slot and ditch your handset?

Janak Parekh
08-28-2003, 01:21 AM
Wait till HP comes out with a ROM upgrade that enables the SIM slot and ditch your handset?
No such thing will ever happen. The only use of the BT Headset profile on the 54/5550 is to listen to audio that would normally come out of the speaker, and maybe to act as a dictaphone/microphone solution. The 5xxx's antennas are not designed for GSM frequencies, and there's no GSM radio in the unit.

--janak

maximus
08-28-2003, 01:50 AM
Wait till HP comes out with a ROM upgrade that enables the SIM slot and ditch your handset?
No such thing will ever happen. The only use of the BT Headset profile on the 54/5550 is to listen to audio that would normally come out of the speaker, and maybe to act as a dictaphone/microphone solution. The 5xxx's antennas are not designed for GSM frequencies, and there's no GSM radio in the unit.

--janak

Dream device : a 400+ mhz PPCPE with wireless headset and CF+SD slots.

Stereo wireless headset will be much appreciated ... we can use it both to make calls, and to listen to music. :mrgreen:

Janak Parekh
08-28-2003, 02:59 AM
Dream device : a 400+ mhz PPCPE with wireless headset and CF+SD slots.
It'll come, in good time. The only problem is, by then, there will be 800+ MHz regular Pocket PCs. :(

Until the wireless (cellular) industry learns how to move faster, non-wireless-enabled (or BT/WiFi-enabled) technologies will stay ahead. This is why BT's promise is so great: you don't have to wait for your carrier to support new cell phones, but you can upgrade the Pocket PC (your interface) easily. We just need BT to become a little more widespread (OK, a lot more widespread.)

--janak

ctmagnus
08-28-2003, 05:26 AM
The 5xxx's antennas are not designed for GSM frequencies, and there's no GSM radio in the unit.

--janak

For the antenna problem, I thought that was what the little round thing on the back, just below the Wi-Fi antenna was for. The lack of GSM hardware didn't even occur to me. :oops:

Oliver T
08-28-2003, 11:47 AM
Stereo wireless headset will be much appreciated ... we can use it both to make calls, and to listen to music.

Hmmm, question is : how good a quality would you get ? The current BT headset profile allows 8kHz, that is not exactly what I would like to listen to ;-) Let's assume that most PDA's still use a standard uart to interface to the BT chip then you are limited to a transfer of 115kbit/s. That translates to a theoretical 11,5 KByte/s (including a bit of protocol overhead). Anybody who ever tried to listen to an internet radio station with that quality setting knows it's not worth it. Maybe that is the real reason why PDA manufacturers don't bother including the headset profile ? It's not even good enough for speech recognition ...

Cheers,

Oliver

maximus
08-29-2003, 02:32 AM
It'll come, in good time. The only problem is, by then, there will be 800+ MHz regular Pocket PCs. :(--janak

Yeah, that is sad. Why don't they make a PPCPE with the latest/fastest processor, and slam a bigger battery on it ? Or use those new lithium sheet ion batteries with 50% more charge density (than the regular lithium ion)?