Thanks for the reply, Mike. That's about the only BT settings I can find on the phone and I did have it set to DISCOVERABLE during the pairing process (or pairing attempt, since I get the same error I mentioned earlier). I've tried it a few times, and get the same error each time.
I really think the problem lies in whatever is causing me to get this error when attempting to pair. I "Googled" the error message and came across others who have gotten the same thing, but no fixes. :?