[Phillip Dyson]

I think the reviewer was really focusing on the form factor and usability when praising the Treo.

I think if you pressed him on why he's still using a pocketpc he would either because the OS is just more powerful.

Of course it could be because he already made the investment and couldn't justify dropping the cash and dealing with the hassle of changing devices.

I agree that the form factor is top notch even with the antenae though I would prefer it without one.

I've never been a fan of convergence, mostly because of the stats of most of the devices. That and the fact that I would be increasing the strangle hold the carriers have over my tech life.

The XDAII was the first device that even remotely tempted to lure me over. A WM5 treo would be even harder.

Actually a decent solution for adding voice to my e830 would be perfect. Then I could carrier either my PDA or Smartphone. Not both.