View Single Post
  #6 (permalink)  
Old 11-13-2003, 03:53 AM
dh
Mystic
dh's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,638

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gee Mont
I tried the free Mobipocket a few months ago and was also disappointed. MS Reader makes for easier and better reading, IMHO, than other readers, and that is what really counts. The activations are a pain, true, but I've never had any real trouble. Anti-DCMA or anti-DRM (or even anti-Microsoft) isn't my weltanschauung. Sorry if that upsets some people, but I'm going to say what I think. It will take more then a few activations to get me to drop MS Reader for a different program.
I love the Mobipocket reader, but the MP DRM is as bad as Microsoft. I had to hard reset my PPC a while ago (I installed that MS Theme Switcher program and it buggered everything up) and could access my one and only Mobipocket secure book.

I usually purchase books in .lit format and convert them to unsecured MP. However I bought the Oxford Dictionary from MP so it's secure.

Anyway, the DRM for MP is tied to the device by a serial number. Hard resetting changes the number. The only cure seems to be to go to the MP site, edit the number in your profile and downloading the book again. I had to do this a couple of times, before I figured out what what was causing me to have to hard reset, the last time MP told me I had reached my limit. WTF? :?

I had to email them to get my limit increased. They responded really quickly, but what a pain in the arse! What if all my books had been in secure MP format? Would I have had to redownload the whole lot of them??

I just hope that Convert Lit doesn't go away because all this DRM stuff is too much for me. If I was starting out I'd go with Palm Reader, but I have a ton of books already.......

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin C. Tofel
To save you the trouble of buying a book to try the DRM: unlike MS Reader where you have to active the book through their site \ servers with a Passport account, the DRM is handled strictly at the device level. You don't need to connect to a website or even have your device in a cradle. You simply enter your name and your credit card number used to purchase the book into the reader application. Very simple and not reliant upon any additional interfaces.....KCT
That seems to be so much better than any of the others, very sensible.
__________________
Cheers!
David
 
Reply With Quote